However, she made the mistake of promising Roger Chillingworth of keeping his identity a secret. Both characters lived in the same time period, however, The Scarlet Letter was written in the late s, and The Crucible was written in the s. She wanted to spill the secret and end the suffering of her lover as well as bring the cruel, old physician to the light Hawthorn, ch.
There were actually seemingly curious about other religions. This is a time when religion is the only basis of government and moral standards. In addition to the similarities in their personalities, Proctor and Dimmesdale are very similar in their physical characteristics.
In the different books, the change of popularity was opposite. Dimmesdale has had sex with Hester Prynne, a woman in the town who has a husband back in England, and Proctor has engaged in sexual congress with Abigail Williams, who had previously been Proctors servant.
Because of his love and secret adoration of Hester and Pearl, Dimmesdale give much stronger sermons that secretly represent, or are directed to his two loves, Scarlet letter and crucible comparison proctor and dimmesd and Hester.
The opinions of the court and the words of the church were all that mattered; they wee above all else because they were believed to carry the will of God.
Everything that Dimmesdale says gets turned into something else. To be against the courts was to be a sinner. Both men have also committed a sin. Both men also hid their secret, which also is one and the same; they both have committed the crime of adultery.
And as the result, she talked to the old physician about whether to maintain the promise or not. His popularity went down because of this.
Every Sunday, he leads the townspeople in worship and tells them to confess their sins. After Abigail was taken for a fraud, she became unpopular, left town, and turned to prostitution. The societies in which these two men live in are also quite alike, yet they do have their differences.
Also, the popularity change between Dimmesdale and Proctor is very clear. Hester admitted that what she committed was wrong and accepted the punishment of being banished from the community of Puritans.
They had to see what was going on with the court, because that is what they held in highest regard. Of the similarities between Proctor and Dimmesdale throughout the book the reader is told that these two men are relatively the same age, and living in approximately the same time period, the s.
Dimmesdale is the minister in his town, and Proctor is a highly respected townsman. Both men, due to their high stature in their respective communities, must keep their sins concealed from the public.
In each Puritan society both men are well respected because of their role in the community. Both Proctor and Dimmesdale are high figures in their respective societies.
Clearly, there is a great relationship between differences and similarities in this romance novel. Because of the stronger sermons, more people were inspired and they took more to Dimmesdale, and liked him more for them. Differences and similarities in the society in which John Proctor and Arthur Dimmesdale live are another important part of this romance novel.
During the play in one of the many conversations, a debate comes up in which it is clearly shown that the courts are the most important establishment of Massachusetts.
Both Hester and Proctor alike tried to restrain the dreadful deeds from progressing any further. Also, if his followers knew about his act of adultery, they would be in a great state of confusion, not knowing to believe in their reverend, their leader, and forgive him, or to get rid of him.
They are both tall, attractive, and in good physical condition. This excerpt describes the other people in the town at this festive time. Among the many similarities between Arthur Dimmesdale and John Proctor, there are a few differences. Works Cited Hawthorne, Nathaniel.
In The Scarlet Letter, the townspeople are so loyal to the "Good Reverend Dimmesdale, " that they are completely blinded by the fact that he is the biggest sinner.
Proctor, who is very religious but does not attend Church regularly, will lose his status in th However, each man has concealed his sin, which for one person or another leads to death.
Even though these two men, Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale and John Proctor, the actions they make, and the societies they live in are quite similar, they are in fact quite different and unique. Dimmesdale as the reverend, or leader of the theocracy, questions his ability to be the leader of all of the people of the community.
John Proctor on the other hand, rarely went to church, and was even criticized for his choice not to attend masses. The penalty thereof is death.Transcript of "The Scarlet Letter" compared to "The Crucible" John Proctor has an affair with Abigail Williams and his wife, Elizabeth, finds out and fires Abigail as their maid.
Abigail wants revenge on Elizabeth so she accuses her of being a witch while hoping she wins John for herself.
Hester. The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible; The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible Essay 11 August The Scarlet Crucible Both Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter include faced, both authors acknowledged that Puritan society at least allowed the ostracized to redeem themselves.
Miller’s Proctor was. People invited to a presentation do not need a Prezi account; A compare and contrast between The Crucible, The Scarlet Letter, and how society influenced the stories Hester kept the identity of pearl's father a secret while Abigail kept her affair with John Proctor a secret.
Roger Chillingworth: young forgiving outspoken careful victims. Comparing John Proctor and Arthur Dimmesdale John Proctor and Arthur Dimmesdale are exceptionally similar characters despite the fact that each was written about in very different eras.
Both characters lived in the same time period, however, The Scarlet Letter was written in the late ’s, and The Crucible was written in the ’s.
Dimmesdale and Proctor, are two of the main characters from books The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible respectively, who goes through many external conflicts. The conflicts that both characters undergo are different from each other.
The Scarlet Letter vs.
the Crucible Essay; The Scarlet Letter vs. the Crucible Essay. The Crucible’s main character John Proctor admits to having committed lechery and is sent to jail for this and for being a Scarlet Letter/Crucible Essay The presence of guilt has been felt by all human beings.
As guilt grows in a person's life it.Download